"This
American Life -- The Problem We All Live With" interview with Nikole H.
Jones was so interesting, not to mention how very naive I am to this type of
research and political power. As I was listening to the interview, I felt glued
to my computer and was filing this new information into my schema, while
attempting to rationalize what I was hearing. As a teacher in Johnston, who
teaches to a diverse population, I had no idea there were schools in the United
States that have teachers who are under qualified. As I read here, (Less Qualified Teachers Hinder Schools with Black and Latino
Kids). "......students of color and low-income students were more likely to attend
schools where teachers were not certified or failed to qualify for their
advanced-level certification following the 5-year expiration of their
entry-level certification. I'm confused as to why schools are hiring those without a teaching certificate. Is it because of a teacher shortage or because the schools are not desirable to teach in? Perhaps it Is because of poor administration.
The article above also points
out that "separate can never be equal," and called on the Department of Education to, "prioritize school diversity as a way to address the resource gap at schools." According to the interview with N.H. Jones, this is the way to lessen the learning gap. The following link provides some claims and evidence regarding the interview with Ira Glass and Nikole Hannah Jones, an investigative reporter at The New York Times.
Here is another article that discusses the importance of not treating all students as if they are the same and to individualize instruction to better serve each individual. (The Growing Diversity in Today’s Classroom) As the article states on page 8, "Personalized learning needs to be aligned with interests and abilities of each learner." If the majority of a student body is categorized as "living in poverty,
have a disability or learning difference, are English language learners, are
gifted or talented, are experiencing challenges at home or in their communities
that result in trauma, or some combination of the above—each of whom research
shows needs personalized approaches to learning." Perhaps the teachers do not have the necessary training or resources to assist students or perhaps school districts want to keep status quo to continue to receive funding.
In reference to how communities shift from culture to culture, I have witnessed a community's gradual cultural change and although this change has been subtle, the population has grown into one other than what once was. The majority of the ethnic background, in one specific community, has shifted from predominantly Italian to Spanish. The generations before lived and worked in this specific area, and spoke Italian freely. Many families and friend's of families moved to this general area because they felt safe and welcomed amongst others who were similar to themselves. (I often wonder who/ what culture was pushed out when the Italians moved in.) As the years passed, and the older generation passed on, more people, other than Italian backgrounds moved in to this exact area. It is pretty awesome how cultures, other than the ones originally situated, have built their homes and families in the surrounding areas and most likely feel that same sense of security and acceptance.
I know that I already published; however, after reading some awesome blogs from our class, I decided to continue on with my research and when I did I came across this report.(More K-12 Funding for White Students vs. People of Color) Again, I am shocked that this is even something to report on. And then this (School Segregation is Getting Worse) How naive I am.

In reference to how communities shift from culture to culture, I have witnessed a community's gradual cultural change and although this change has been subtle, the population has grown into one other than what once was. The majority of the ethnic background, in one specific community, has shifted from predominantly Italian to Spanish. The generations before lived and worked in this specific area, and spoke Italian freely. Many families and friend's of families moved to this general area because they felt safe and welcomed amongst others who were similar to themselves. (I often wonder who/ what culture was pushed out when the Italians moved in.) As the years passed, and the older generation passed on, more people, other than Italian backgrounds moved in to this exact area. It is pretty awesome how cultures, other than the ones originally situated, have built their homes and families in the surrounding areas and most likely feel that same sense of security and acceptance.
I know that I already published; however, after reading some awesome blogs from our class, I decided to continue on with my research and when I did I came across this report.(More K-12 Funding for White Students vs. People of Color) Again, I am shocked that this is even something to report on. And then this (School Segregation is Getting Worse) How naive I am.

Hi Jamie! You make an interesting point in your final paragraph about a community moving from heavily Italian based to becoming a community where the majority of the folks living there are Spanish. It is interesting to me because you never really hear stories in the news of Italians being discriminated against or in any type of danger, but is always a huge issue to people in the majority, mainly white folks, when an influx of non-white people move into their neighborhoods and they always complain how they feel "unsafe." Great job!
ReplyDeleteHi Jamie- One sentence in your post struck a chord with me that I never even thought of through all this listening and reading about low SES schools, integration and access to equal education. I have nothing to back up the claim but maybe something to research. You wrote, "perhaps school districts want to keep status quo to continue to receive funding." Would funding be withdrawn if the student's scores were to rise? Or is funding based on the SES of the area? I did write in my blog that maybe the states need to pool the tax money and distribute the money evenly to fund the schools. However, it still doesn't solve the problem of segregation. And how statistically students do better when they are integrated. What is making the students more successful? Is it the integration, Being exposed to experienced/qualified teachers, better facilities and rigorous classes or both. There is certainly a lot to consider.
ReplyDeleteI agree with your question regarding why are these schools hiring less qualified teachers? It might be that they do have a certificate, but they do not have as much experience so they are termed "less qualified"? Also, when I was in undergrad we talked about this issue that many highly qualified teachers are white and of middle/upper class and they go back into the same communities from which they came, to teach. It creates a vicious cycle where the urban, low income schools get less qualified teachers because teachers are deterred from working there. I personally enjoy the challenge of working in a predominately black/latino school that has a mixture of low income and middle class families. It is difficult yes, but I know that the work I do is important. I always remembered what my professor said, to teach somewhere urban/low income because sometimes they need us the most.
ReplyDeleteI am glad that this piece was so powerful for you -- sometimes hearing the voices of real people articulating their own narrative can be even more educational than reading about it! I agree with your peers that these questions about WHY are key. While complex and difficult, there is also something very easy about desegregation being a system that has a proven track record and really works to create more equity and access. And yet...
ReplyDelete